Texans For Texas
Janelle Shepard, Director

Texas Workers' Compensation Woes
by Janelle Shepard, Director, Texans For Texas, Inc.


The workers’ compensation insurance is a state-regulated insurance program that pays medical bills and replaces some lost wages for employees who are injured at work or who have work-related diseases or illnesses. The Texas system was reinvented in 1989 under a select legislative committee. 

Highlights included voluntary participation.  An employer choosing to participate in the coverage is protected from lawsuits.  With improved benefits, benefits delivery, dispute resolution, cost controls, attorneys’ fees, and workplace safety, Texans hoped the solution would be long lasting.  (see TWCC history)

Well, it is a new century and the system players in Texas are clamoring for relief. 

 

Injured workers, employers, physicians, insurance carriers, and chiropractors are wanting better conditions (meaning more money) and fewer hassles (meaning more money faster!) 

 

James Bernsen with The Lone Star Report (LSR) states: “Finding supporters of the status quo at the commission may be hard. Texas consistently ranks among the worst states in terms of both outcomes – a low return-to-work rate and cost. Texas costs are well beyond the national average.

The only state that does worse in most rankings is
California. But California just passed a comprehensive workers comp overhaul under Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.”

 

After a blistering Sunset Commission report regarding the Texas Workers Compensation Commission in the spring, many expressed their opinions.



"Distrust abounds.  Employers distrust physicians... Physicians distrust... Injured workers distrust employers.. Chiropractors distrust physicians...
"


“What I would say, and what I think what everybody knows, is that the current process is broken,” said Darren Whitehurst, director of public affairs for the Texas Medical Association. “I don’t think there’s anybody who likes the current process. Not employers, not employees, not the carriers, not the providers, not anybody.” LSR 4/23/04

Texas Association of Business has this opening statement in it's position paper, "Cashing in on Worker's Compensation"

The Texas Workers’ Compensation system finds itself on the verge of collapse because of spiraling medical costs. Carriers on average are paying out a $1.38 for every dollar they receive in premiums because they have few tools to control costs. Texas employers, committed to finding quality care for their injured workers, are finding it difficult to find affordable coverage or any coverage at all.  And, as always, it is the small employers who are bearing the brunt of this hard market. 

 












>>
continued top of next column

Distrust abounds.  Employers distrust physicians and physicians distrust ‘light’ duty for injured workers.  Injured workers distrust employers for not reporting accidents due to fears of higher premiums.  Chiropractors distrust physicians and likewise, thus - the return to work dates are lengthy and costly. 

California just passed a comprehensive workers comp overhaul under Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger

The cost of medical care has driven insurance companies to distrust injured workers as patients try to claim non-work related health issues not covered under workers’ compensation.

 

 

Study up!  The issues will affect every employer and employee in the state.  It will also determine the future economic growth for Texas.  

All business owners, small and large, will examine the worker compensation climate before moving to or building their company in
Texas.

 

We will provide expert testimony and research to you in the future.

Committee members are listed below.  Contact them with your thoughts.


 

House Committee on Construction-Related Workers' Comp, Select

Legislative Session: 78(4)


Appointment Date
: 11/04/2003
Clerk: Teri Avery
Phone: 463-0514
Room:

Co-Chair:
Co-Chair:
   
Members:
                   
                   
                   
                   
                   




Senate Committee on Workers' Compensation, Select Interim

Legislative Session: 78(4)


Appointment Date
: 12/15/2003
Clerk: Patricia Gajda
Phone: 463-0067
Room: SHB 445

Chair:
   
Members:
                   
                   
                   
                   
                   
                   
                   
                   


ARTICLE ARCHIVE
PREVIOUS ISSUES

HOME


Janelle Shepard

Editor of TX4TX Newsletter, registered nurse with 25 years experience. 20 yr political veteran.

Parker County resident, near Fort Worth / Dallas.